Webdeveloper from Germany, nerd, gamer, atheist, interested in nerd-culture, biology of everything creepy, evolution, history, physics, politics and space.

Progressive. Ally. SocDem. Euro-Federalist.

Political Compass: -7.0, -6.62

  • 5 Posts
  • 537 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 24th, 2024

help-circle
  • I don’t know, the current level of killing is unprecedented. Even during the height of the Nakba, Israel mostly created refugees. The Netanyahu-Government has upped the level of brutality to heights that do not compare to previous campaigns. But I think everyone is aware that this didn’t start 2023 but is an ongoing situation since 1948.


  • I’m just an old dude who reads statistics and studies as a hobby and enjoys combing through sources. I don’t know about how fast or extensive help could arrive in Gaza, this is only how I understand the numbers and studies, so please take these educated guesses as just that. Nothing written here is the unchangeable truth.

    As I understand it, statistically, those lives are most likely lost, as 4:1 is already a very conservative estimate I don’t believe there is much that actually can be done there. Realistically it is a nigh impossible task with the current Israeli Government in power and with where majority opinions in Israel land.

    But! What can be done is to stop that number from rising even more.

    Human aid, medicine convoys and medical personell need fast, safe and reliable access to Gaza. The humanitarian catastrophe is already there and the longer aid is restricted, the worse it will become. We’re talking starvation, sickness and cold but also missing infrastructure and succumbing to treatable wounds.

    And I beg you to remember: As bad as it is, the death toll is not even half of the entire picture. The survivors won’t live happily ever after. The number of serious, life-altering injuries is usually higher than the death toll. That means amputees, people dramatically disfigured or disabled, not to mention the horrific mental consequences of living through something like that. And all of them still need help.

    Just because we cannot save all doesn’t mean in the slightest that giving up is even an option!


  • The numbers put out by the Gaza Ministry of Health have been consistently found to underestimate the real numbers of directly conflict related deaths by ~ 35%

    The 150k estimate includes solely direct conflict related deaths, not indirect deaths like cold, starvation and lack of medicine.




  • Enkrod@feddit.orgtoPolitical Memes@lemmy.world•Reminder
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    37
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    17 hours ago

    I see lots of numbers getting thrown around. So I’ll do my thing and try to give an informed estimate, hoping that it’ll help the discussion.

    tl;dr: Likely number of people dead definitely over 100.000, likely number of casulties overall if fighting were to stop immediately still gives a lowest estimate of ~ 377.930

    My edits: lots of typos and clarification.


    Let’s get some numbers

    Let’s look at a study from Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research (MPIDR) and the Centre for Demographic Studies (CED). The study is from March 2025, so the numbers are not current, but they give you an idea.

    First: Can we trust the numbers?

    Recent studies have found no evidence of systematic overreporting in Gaza Ministry of Health data, so it’s safe to work with those. In fact recent results from the Gaza Mortality Survey, a large-scale household survey, suggest that conflict-related deaths from October 7, 2023 to January 5, 2025 substantially exceeded official reports, with the GMoH’s reported death toll approximately 35% below the survey’s central estimate. So the Gaza Ministry of Health appears quite trustworthy not to overestimate numbers.

    The study itself seems also quite trustworthy, since it’s estimate aligns with the actual data from the Gaza Mortality Survey.

    Our conflict-related death toll estimate of 78,318 (70,614-87,504) by the end of 2024 closely aligns with the independently conducted Gaza Mortality Survey’s estimate of 75,200 (63,600-86,800) violent deaths between October 7, 2023, and January 5, 2025

    The study suggests that:

    a conservative estimate would assume four indirect deaths for every direct death in Gaza

    So 4 indirect to every 1 direct death, that means we multiply “conflict related deaths” by 5 to get a total number. And 5 is a conservative estimate, because for example Sierra Leone, another protracted conflict had a 16:1 ratio. But I think going conservative is the correct way, because:

    Non-violent excess deaths, although substantial, are lower than some projections have suggested.

    Sauce

    Ok, let’s get current numbers.

    Gaza Health Ministey says since Oct. 7 until September 2026 there have been at least 75,586 Palestinians killed in conflict related deaths (counting only those that were officially reported). Including at least 21,000 children. Those numbers seem to be used by the CIA and the Mossad, though neither Israel nor the US officially accept them. This is 3% of the pre-war population.

    Speculation

    Now if we multiply this by 5 we get a lowest, conservative estimate of 377.930 deaths if we include cold, starvation, lack of medicine and other indirect causes. This corresponds to 18% of Gazas pre-war population of 2.1 million.

    But remember! This number includes people who have yet to die because of already set in stone statistics. Even if fighting stopped today and international help arrives immediately, that number would still be reached in the aftermath, but likely hasn’t been reached yet.

    The study says that the direct and indirect numbers almost certainly already exceed 100.000, but more importantly, life expectancy in the Gaza Strip has fallen by 47% (2024 numbers), equivalent of losses of 36.4 years. Life expectancy in Gaza is now only 40.4 years! For men it is 36.2 years, for women it is 45.9 years.

    The study also found that the age and gender distribution of violent deaths in Gaza between October 7, 2023, and December 31, 2024, closely resembled the demographic patterns observed in several genocides documented by the United Nations Inter-Agency Group for Child Mortality Estimation (UN IGME).

    The study itself was not concerned with wheather this is a genocide or not. But it clearly states that it has the hallmarks of one.


  • But more often than not, their attitudes are a reflection of their age. This bitch is straight up evil and still fondly remembers Jim Crow.

    She voted against same-sex marriage, against healthcare, against releasing the Epstein Files, against helping the victims of hurricane Katrina, against racial justice and against legalizing abortions in cases of rape.

    All those positions are overwhelmingly carried by people above the age of 60. With support strongly correlating to age, voting out the undead will greatly improve political positions in the House.





  • I’ve been to a big pagan festival, there was a huge bonfire in the middle of the campground and about two dozen people were sitting around it playing mostly drums but also other instruments. Then a woman with a fiddle started playing this really catchy tune and people just started dancing, and jumping around the fire, barely clothed and just… enjoying themselves. Sure, MJ and alcohol might have been involved with some few people, but most of us were just high on the moment, watching the sparks of the fire float into a clear, starry, warm night sky.

    All of it in front of this backdrop:

    We were all so happy, so light, so warm, everybody was friends with everybody, even though nobody knew anybody else, you could drift through the little groups, share a story with a stranger, go to another one of the small fires, share a beer with them, learning and immediately forgetting their names and all the eyes around you were soft and friendly and curious. The passion of life ran through our veins and the feeling of being young and alive was overwhelming. Me and my GF fucked like rabbits that night in our tent, still listening to the music and the noise of people singing and laughing and I can still feel her lips on my collarbone when I think back to how we sat at the fire and just… existed.