• 1 Post
  • 791 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 8th, 2025

help-circle

  • Most of the ML arguments about why immediate communism wouldn’t work revolve around the fact that in every historical revolution that burned down Parliament, the capitalists, with all of their wealth and power, still existed and fought with everything they had to rebuild Parliament. Not to mention that most of the people were still heavily influenced by capitalist ideology and superstructures. Doesn’t seem realistic to expect communism to survive without a centralized army to defend it and a coherent society and economy to supply it, and it doesn’t seem realistic for a society that immediately tries for communism to be coherent.


  • I’ve been called a tankie, and I understand completely what your vision of an ideal future is. A classless, moneyless, stateless society— aka communism. “Tankies” also want this future, we just disagree on how to get there.

    I could also say that ML positions have to be broken down to their simplest terms for the libs and “anarkiddies”, but I don’t actually think that would convince most people. In the case of the libs, class consciousness is something that must be arrived at via lived experience. We can try to propagandize, but propaganda on its own is not effective. In the case of the anarchists, we just fundamentally have different views on how the world works and the ability of disparate anarchist communities to fight capitalist state power. I would be happy to be proven wrong if the transition to communism can happen without a worker’s state to repress capitalist reaction, but I find that possibility extremely unlikely.

    Ultimately, I don’t think arguing these points is worthwhile when we are nowhere close to the class consciousness required for either an anarchist or ML strategy to achieve communism. And in the meantime, throwing slurs like tankie or anarkiddy only serves to divide us and empower the capitalists.


  • As in any good socialist system, the fact that greed and competition are not incentivized by the system goes a long way to limiting whatever aspect of those traits is innate.

    And I would argue that most humans are not actually greedy. The desire to consolidate is actually good for socialism, after all, it’s about communities, not individuals. And competition is fine, just not when it’s for necessities, which it wouldn’t be because, again, it’s socialism.



  • The point of that example was how something was racist even though it wasn’t originally intended to be racist or the people doing it were intending to be racist.

    Chinese people don’t use that meme anymore. It’s almost exclusively foreigners. And in that context, with the history of racist yellow caricatures, the meme is racist. It’s honestly odd that you’re defending it this much.









  • Socialist power has never hinged on bourgeois electoral processes. So yes, the bourgeois is gathering the reins of its power to itself, but as they do that, and the working class awakens more and more to the fact that they are excluded from bourgeois democracy, alternate forms of power will be formed. Hopefully leading to a revolutionary moment that can dismantle bourgeoise democracy and enact socialist democracy.

    I agree that doesn’t seem likely in this moment, but dialectical analysis suggests this is how revolutions happen, by the ruling class hoarding power and wealth too much in the face of growing worker’s demands.


  • Let’s be clear, accelerationism is a morally bankrupt strategy and never works to the degree its proponents think it will. But it is also undeniable that leftist ideologies have not been this popular in America since the 1920s.

    It’s not entirely due to Trump, but rather the dialectical relationship between the capitalist mode of production and the innate human rejection of oppression.