• 8 Posts
  • 272 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 21st, 2023

help-circle

  • LesserAbe@lemmy.worldtoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.world•book burning
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    17
    ·
    4 months ago

    This article I just saw elsewhere on lemmy does claim that the books are rare. But it seems to be misleading. In one point it talks about Dutch antiquarian book collectors receiving requests. But if you click through to the source story (Dutch) it says, “Usually the spam button was quickly pressed, because it was hardly serious to take. Antiquarians only deal in very old books: titles that stem from the time before ISBN codes existed at all.”

    Again, I don’t like what these companies are doing, and wouldn’t be opposed to legislation against it. But it’s good to be factual and understand what is actually happening.

    Having an ISBN number doesn’t guarantee there is a digital copy somewhere else or that a significant number of physical copies exist. But it makes it more likely.



  • I remember watching Battlestar Galactica, where they talked about how they refused to wire the ships systems together so at to prevent AI from hacking them. And the one time they had to manually connect the different systems for plot reasons, the AI hacked into them in comically fast real time. I thought it was hokey at the time, but this sounds surprisingly similar. (although less murderous)



  • Yeah, it’s in AI companies interest to hype how all powerful their product is. I’m not necessarily talking about that.

    When I say potentially, I’m not a doomer, so not trying to say there’s no hope, I do think we can make the world better than it is.

    That said, one example of dystopian future: one of my clients makes networked security cameras. I saw a presentation where they were showing off their AI search capability. They had a static shot of an expressway, with hours of footage, and they said “I want to find a person in a bus wearing a brown shirt” and just like that pulled up the relevant moment. Not something you want an authoritarian to have. They’re going to get it anyways. But would love to have similar power available to the people.

    Likewise when you think about accumulation of capital, which is shorthand for accumulation of power. AI will allow elites to accelerate that accumulation and have less use for people. “Who cares if you go on strike? I don’t need you.”

    Having open source AI can turn the tables: “Who cares if you raised the price? I’ll make it myself.”



  • LesserAbe@lemmy.worldtoTechnology@lemmy.world•Opensource AI Must Win
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    5 months ago

    You’re right, we don’t “need” most modern conveniences. But they save us time and provide an improved quality of life. Why do we need power tools? Why motors? Why electricity, running water, artificial light? I joke, but AI is one of a long chain of tools designed to save us time, or extend our capabilities and reach. Why are you particularly opposed to this one over others? I return to my argument: AI is concerning because of its potential for change. I don’t think we can prevent it from existing, but we can make it accessible to normal people and not solely the domain of the rich.


  • LesserAbe@lemmy.worldtoTechnology@lemmy.world•Opensource AI Must Win
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    5 months ago

    It doesn’t need to be our new cyber god for it to matter. All the software developers I know use AI as a tool. One person I know who heads a department at a publicly traded company you’ve probably heard of said they’re not hiring more junior developers, and is worried about his long term career outlook.

    That’s concerning right? Capitalists who have a choice between hiring ten people or hiring one person who supervises an AI doing the work of nine are going to choose the cheaper option, and pocket the difference.

    To say that LLMs are not useful to me indicates a lack of familiarity. I’m not taking about bullshit “write this email for me” type stuff, I mean like “write this web app for me” “find this type of document in this massive trove of documents” “troubleshoot this technical issue”. And it can do it.

    LLMs are not replacing humans, but they are reducing labor required for many tasks. Who receives the benefit from that reduced labor? Right now, owners. That’s why I support open source AI or preferably democratic-entity-only open source AI.


  • LesserAbe@lemmy.worldtoTechnology@lemmy.world•Opensource AI Must Win
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    5 months ago

    I don’t see it as fear mongering. What do you think of open source software like Linux, Firefox, VLC and so on? Because a similar argument is made there - we need to use these tools day to day, and the only option being to pay a corporation to use them would make us literally poorer, and we also wouldn’t have the features and quality we see in Windows, Mac, Chrome etc if there weren’t open source competitors.

    Is lack of open source AI currently a civilizational existential threat? No. Could it be if current trends continue? Potentially. Things could get pretty dystopian if only the mega rich control tools with ultra-intelligence.

    There are some open models right now, but they’re mostly ones created by private enterprise that were released to the public. Creating models is more resource intensive than making open source software. So it makes sense to pool resources for the public good.


  • LesserAbe@lemmy.worldtoTechnology@lemmy.world•Opensource AI Must Win
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    5 months ago

    You’re right that global warming is an existential threat. And right now the power grid is contributing to it.

    At the same time, we’re seeing constant innovations in solar power and battery technology, while the cost of both are going down. Solar is now the cheapest source of energy per unit. There is enough energy from the sun to cover multiples of all current energy use by humans.

    AI models started out as extremely energy intensive, but are becoming increasingly more efficient. You can now run models on your phone with abilities which previously required a server running dedicated graphics cards.

    You’re also right that we shouldn’t outsource critical thinking. Still to say AI has “all the worst use cases” is wrong. Yes, it has plenty of bad use cases, by many great ones. I use it in my day to day work to save time.

    Something like a law banning the use of AI will never pass, and if it did, other countries wouldn’t also pass it. A country which uses AI will outperform one that does not (economically, although probably militarily as well). In that scenario, leaving AI capability in the hands of private enterprise makes us subject to the whims of rich elites. For an analog see the case of Elon Musk turning Starlink on/off in Ukraine. Which again is why I do think there’s value in open source AI, and more specifically AI only available to democratically controlled entities - nation states but also things like worker cooperatives to compete with corporations.


  • LesserAbe@lemmy.worldtoTechnology@lemmy.world•Opensource AI Must Win
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    5 months ago

    I bet me and the person I’m responding to have a ton in common. Likewise me and the person who wrote that post. But I don’t relate to the position of “all AI should stop.”

    I think there should be democratically accountable AI development. I’m interested in open source but the problem with it is that private corporations take advantage of it until they get big enough to try to lock out competitors. (See Google with Android) I would love to see an “open source” license which allows use by individuals and democratic entities, but forbids use by private enterprise.


  • LesserAbe@lemmy.worldtoTechnology@lemmy.world•Opensource AI Must Win
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    23
    arrow-down
    6
    ·
    5 months ago

    It’s not going to. Saying all AI should stop is like saying “all gunpowder should stop”. Would everyone be better off if no one was using it? Maybe. But that’s not going to happen at this point, and will give you a strategic disadvantage if you unilaterally disarm.

    And to be clear I’m not talking about using AI to write a screenplay or something creative, I mean like using it to write software, to optimize industrial processes etc.







  • I’ve read into it a little bit - basically every day every participant gets the Universal Dividend. It’s the same for everyone. Supposing you had every person on earth participating, they all get the same thing every day.

    The next part I feel like we should skip explaining to the casual observer, because it’s not so simple:

    Everyone gets 1 Universal Dividend per day. The Universal Dividend consists of x number of G1/June coins. That x amount is defined mathematically based on the number of participants. So fewer coins are issued today with let’s say 10k users, and more coins are issued in the future with 100k users.

    The system is inherently inflationary. If all users, people who have been doing it for 20 years and those doing it 2 days, didn’t make any further transactions, after 40 years their wallet balances would effectively be the same.

    Of course if the system is a success, people will be making transactions. But the idea is to encourage commercial exchange, rather than people hoarding because they think it will be worth more in the future.

    The value isn’t in the coin, the value is being able to transact with other people without resorting to barter. If you have to work for someone else or borrow in order to perform transactions, then you will be beholden to those who have already accumulated a lot of wealth.

    This system doesn’t solve the fact that somebody owns a factory, and somebody owns an apartment building, and someone owns the farm land and so on. But it would help the issue where the federal reserve can generate billions of dollars at a keystroke which are made available to big banks to lend to the public with interest, and which simultaneously devalues the dollars in your wallet.

    This system is inflationary, like federal money creation is inflationary, but at least those inflated coins are being put in normal people’s wallets instead of a handful of big banks. It helps defend against the accumulation of billionaires.


  • The OP makes it seems like they lost money by making poor trades, which so far in the history of Ethereum you could do in a very short period, but not if you held onto it for any length of time.

    You’re right, they could have lost it by scams or hacks. The power to instantly transact with anyone in the world is a feature, but also a risk.

    If crypto takes off for actual day to day transactions I imagine there will be an intermediate layer of banks or other institutions that take on some of the risk but also take their cut.

    Anarchist types are concerned about government backed crypto coins since you lose the fungibility/anonymity of physical dollars but don’t get any of the freedom and separation from centralization that crypto supposedly represents.