• 1 Post
  • 288 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 13th, 2023

help-circle
  • the bourgeois are not the enemy - it’s the hyper capitalists

    Yes, the bourgeois. Bourgeois means business owners or people who own capital.

    Not sure exactly what you’re meaning by “middle class”, but I’m guessing it’s white collar workers (people who’s job is telling other people what to do) and/or “petite bourgeois” (aka small business owners like small tradie businesses or mum and pop shops).









  • Mr Fish@lemmy.worldtoFediverse@lemmy.world•Huh
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    6 months ago

    the fediverse is too complex to free people from centralized stuff

    Not really, people understood email just fine, and fediverse isn’t that different. The problem is there’s a major subtle push to make anything open source look way more complex than it is. It’s basically an open secret that microsoft did this with linux, and I’d be shocked if social media companies aren’t doing the same.

    it’s extremely biased towards leftism

    That’s inevitable. Anything foss will appeal far more to the anti corporate/ anti capitalist leftist people.



  • The usual complaint: American democrats are shit and don’t deserve your vote.

    And the usual response: I agree, but what alternative are you suggesting? Not voting, or voting third party in fptp means you’re choosing to have less impact than you otherwise would.

    Also, for context: I’m not American, I just have an understanding of current events. I’m not a liberal, I’m very much a leftist, but also a realist.



  • can you not have auth left and lib left viewpoints?

    Yes, but actually no. The distinction is fundamentally unstable. If the left is constantly questioning power structures, it will inevitably turn to whatever structure the auth left comes up with.

    what’s wrong with the definition of left and right on the political compass?

    It’s specially economic left/right, which is almost always defined by taxation, government spending, and social welfare. While leftists usually say social welfare is a good thing, it’s not changing the fundamentals of how capitalism works, which is the current dominant power structure that leftists are against.

    do auth left not also take issue with the power capitalist businesses have?

    Yes, but they usually put something just as bad in its place. You might have heard people saying that the USSR was “state capitalist rather than communist”. This means that the workers and customers had just as little say in how things are run than they would under capitalists, only is was directly with the state rather than individual business owners.



  • It comes from the French revolution, when the people who wanted a better king sat on the right side of the debate room, and people who wanted to get rid of the king sat on the left. From my understanding, right wing is about incremental improvement on what currently exists (optimistically, current right wing isn’t even about this), while left wing is about questioning what exists and redesigning it from the ground up.


  • Only on the political compass, which uses a definition of left vs right that a lot of leftists disagree with. Really, the entire history of “left wing” politics has been about questioning and dismantling authority. The terms “left wing” and “right wing” come from the French revolution, when the people in favour of simply reforming the monarchy sat on the right side of the room, while the people who wanted to fully dismantling the monarchy sat on the left. A lot of more modern leftist thought is about questioning the power that capitalist businesses have.