• 25 Posts
  • 193 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 9th, 2024

help-circle


  • If her husband’s family is patriarchical and religious, then that’s simply the case regardless of whether or not they are Indonesian.

    But if that’s the case regardless, then why did OP mention their ethnicity? And why did she mention her own?

    We all need to remember that Indonesia was colonized by Europeans for 350 years. That colonization included theft of land, slavery, and mass killings.

    Much of this was buried until 2022 when, after an investigation, the Netherlands finally apologized.

    So I don’t think this is quite the same as you hanging around an American church group unless that church group was composed of Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous peoples.

    More to the point, Europeans shouldn’t be implying their culture is more “progressive” than others when Europeans spent hundreds of years oppressing others in the pursuit of extractive wealth.


  • It is true that the the title and embedded tweet may refer to two different people, but I can safely assume that, based on the post title, OP is who she says she is and the tweet aligns with her experience.

    OP deliberately paired the image with a post title about being Swedish, progressive, and married into an Indonesian family.

    It is likewise true that children have some degree of agency. Not as much as adults do, but some nonetheless. And it might be true OP is just teaching children the skills of critical thinking—I’ve already allowed that this might be the case.

    But since she’s framed herself as young, progressive, and Swedish, I am equally right to be skeptical about her ability to question her own biases.

    OP decided to point out her husband’s family is Indonesian. She didn’t have to have to do this.

    Finally, when did I say that Europeans cannot introduce ideas into other cultures without committing imperialism? That is a textbook strawman when my objection isn’t to OP’s ideas but to the Eurocentrism.

    She explicitly contrasted her Swedish progressive identity with her husband’s Indonesian family, framing European culture as enlightened and non-European culture as backward and in need of correction.


  • You offer such an extraordinary amount of charitable good faith to OP that it verges on gaslighting.

    But I will extend extra good faith of my own by pointing out you are defending the woman’s good intentions while I’m pointing out that—regardless of her intentions—her post is troublesome all the same.

    She might be genuinely well-intentioned, sincerely feminist, and interested in helping children think critically. Fine.

    None of that establishes that her framing is free of Eurocentric assumptions. You don’t have to consciously endorse racial or cultural hierarchies to reproduce them.

    You’ve also inadvertently reinforced my central argument: you describe feminism as progressive ideas the woman “inherited from her cultural background.”

    But feminism isn’t uniquely Swedish or European. And actually, Indonesia has its own substantial feminist history.

    Treating progressive values as something Europeans bring to non-European societies Is white supremacist as hell.

    And your appeal to cultural exchange doesn’t address the asymmetry. Sure, cultural exchange goes both ways. That’s true, but OP isn’t describing a reciprocal exchange.

    Instead, she’s celebrating her status as a Swedish woman introducing her progressive worldview to an Indonesian family. Nothing in the post suggests she’s similarly interested in questioning her own cultural assumptions.

    Finally, you’re attacking an expectation I didn’t express. Nobody demanded that the woman write paragraphs disavowing colonialism or racism.

    My criticism is about what she chose to emphasize, specifically her Swedish identity and supposedly progressive values against her husband’s Indonesian family.


  • What exactly do you mean by “everything else”? You’re making a vague accusation without identifying a single specific argument you disagree with.

    My central criticism is that OP frames herself as a young, enlightened, progressive Swedish woman in contrast to her Indonesian husband’s family. That framing reproduces a familiar Eurocentric narrative in which Europeans bring enlightenment to supposedly backward non-Europeans.

    You can challenge religious conservatism without reproducing that kind of cultural hierarchy.

    If you think my interpretation is wrong, explain why. Simply calling everything you disagree with a “wild assumption” isn’t an argument.



  • It’s one thing to challenge religion and conservative beliefs.

    It’s quite another thing to frame herself as an enlightened outsider bringing progressive values to a supposedly backward family.

    Especially when this post makes it a point to trumpet her as young, Swedish, and progressive, in contrast to her husband’s Indonesian family—which is supposedly not.

    It’s further suspicious when she treats children as instruments of ideological conflict. If it’s merely a matter of teaching young people to think critically—okay. But if this is just an exercise in trying to get children to adopt her particular conclusions, she’s teaching them nothing except another prescriptive moral stance.

    She also prides herself on making others question their assumptions. But how willing is she to question her own? If she’s just administering criticism without doing her own self-examination, then I question whether she’s applying this principle universally.

    Finally, posting this on social media is quite performative. The post is structured around the satisfaction she derives from being a disruptive presence at family gatherings. The children, religion, and patriarchy are supporting characters in a story about her own self-image.

    For this reason, I don’t think she’s quite deserving of a high-five.











  • You’re missing why Trails matters.

    This isn’t about “a lot of games.” It’s about building something no other JRPG studio has ever pulled off—a single, continuous saga that’s been unfolding since Trails in the Sky in 2004.

    No resets, no reboots, no discarded lore. Every event, faction, and character connects across a dozen titles. That kind of long-form narrative discipline doesn’t exist anywhere else in the genre.

    And don’t minimize how hard that is. Most JRPG studios can barely keep one trilogy coherent. Falcom has been weaving one uninterrupted storyline for over twenty years—through console generations and shifting hardware.

    Holding a narrative together across decades isn’t just impressive, it’s almost impossible. Doing this wasn’t just because of luck. It’s taken discipline, patience, and vision on a scale no other studio has matched.

    Influence is easy to trace. XSEED’s Trails in the Sky localization raised the bar for how seriously Western publishers approach text-heavy JRPGs. At the time, bringing over a game with hundreds of thousands of lines of dialogue was considered unworkable. They did it, and it set a precedent for the kind of effort fans now expect from localizations.

    Falcom also helped legitimize PC as a JRPG platform in the West—back when most people dismissed the genre as “console only.”

    And if you look at modern RPGs built around serialized storytelling and grounded politics—Disco Elysium, Baldur’s Gate 3, even the way Persona 5 structures its arcs—you can see Falcom’s fingerprints everywhere.

    Critics agree. RPG Site flat out said this about the remake of Trails in the Sky FC:

    If you’re here strictly for the magical number, here it is: Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter remake is a 10/10. What’s more, it’s the easiest 10/10 I’ve ever given.”

    https://rpgsite.net/review/18452-trails-in-the-sky-1st-chapter-review

    And the numbers back it up. Trails in the Sky sits at Overwhelmingly Positive on Steam with a 93% approval rating from thousands of reviews. Recent reviews are even better—96% positive.

    https://store.steampowered.com/app/251150/The/_Legend/_of/_Heroes/_Trails/_in/_the/_Sky/

    Rather than burning energy on outrage, put that time into actually playing more games. You’ll get more out of them—and you’re better than just dismissing something this significant.