• 0 Posts
  • 558 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: November 24th, 2025

help-circle





  • freagle@lemmy.mltoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.world•Pet anarchists
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    This is mostly because of different theories about reality. Anarchists are ideologically committed to the position of prefiguration - the idea that the way you get somewhere must be shaped like the place you’re trying to go. They categorically deny the possibility of getting somewhere by going somewhere else first.

    Marxists apply systems theory to human society and have arrived at the analysis that the way we got here was a complex series of developments that produced the conditions for the next complex series of developments. For example, it was impossible to have a stock market for securities exchange before the systems existed from money, common stock, and corporations.

    The Marxist path towards a stateless society is a series of transitions that deal with the current shape of the system and the system controls that rebalance the system towards its current state. The anarchist path towards a stateless society is to just declare a stateless society and either destroy or ignore anything that disagrees so that whatever they are building can replace it.

    We can use all sorts of metaphors for this. Marxists look at a self balancing system and look at dismantle the pistons or the sensors that balance it where as the anarchists just thinks we should just all crowd to one side of the platform and make it unbalanced through being unbalanced.

    Or the Marxist and the anarchist are both trying to head West but they come to a deep river full of alligators and hippos. The Marxist decides to follow the river North to look for a crossing, but the Anarchist argued that they can’t go West by going North and they jump and try to swim West.

    Prefiguration is a ridiculous ideological position that assumes reality is fundamentally driven by values as opposed to the other way around. A Marxist might identify that the cause of a subset of precarity is dependence on the hierarchy to produce medically necessary drugs. The Marxist might then size the hierarchy and over produce these drugs, freeing this subset of people from precarity and adding them to the revolutionary movement. The anarchist would argue that using the hierarchy is a nonstarter, and that the best way to produce an abundance of these drugs is to distribute drug production kits to every family that needs them with the end result being that those people remain in precarity until someone figures out how to scale that prefigured idea without using hierarchy. One moves the system towards a new state through stages, the other refuses to move the system until the ideas are worked out.

    Marxism explicitly acknowledges that the nature of globe spanning complex systems is ultimately unknowable a priori and therefore must proceed in stages guided by an awareness of how systems work to avoid progress towards a new stage being undermined by movement back towards the prior stable point. That means analyzing what is and experimenting at the systems levels to understand the mechanisms that reassert system stability for states that are inherently unstable (like class society). It also means analyzing what emerges as progress is made to understand what other aspects of instability and stability emerge that we don’t know yet.

    Anarchism throws all of that out the window and asserts that nothing is worth doing unless it is ideologically purified of specific errors (unjust hierarchy being the primary one). It’s a moral/idealist position that operates on the assumption that things are the way they are because of a moral failing (hierarchy) and that any attempt to change anything on anyway while maintaining acceptance of a hierarchy is not merely doomed to fail but worthy of being actively destroyed.


  • If you’re Han, the ethnic unity law is fine. But if you aren’t, things get a little murky.

    I assume you’re speaking from experience? Or maybe you’ve read some sociology research I haven’t seen. I’m sure you’re not just reading sinophobic “journalism” and regurgitating their talking points without verifying them first.

    And how many genocides have happened in China since those countries you mentioned have been around? It isn’t zero.

    The Han had one against the indigenous on the island of Taiwan, and one against Shaanxi. The Manchu had one against the Mongols. There were other smaller extermination campaigns by various ethnicities against other ethnicities over the last 600 years. But it’s important to understand that these are within the basin, making them effectively equivalent to intra-european ethnic conflict, of which there were about 8 major ethnic cleansing campaigns. So about on par with China.

    Where things diverge is that while those intra-european campaigns were going on, the European blue ocean powers were also commiting genocide, ethnic cleansing, and colonial atrocities against the rest of world in addition.

    Every major civilizational basin saw intense ethnic conflict within their borders: China, Europe, Persia, the multiple hubs of Africa (e.g. the Sahel, the Nile valley, the Southern plateaus), and the various hubs in “the Americas”. They all produced ethnic violence within their civilization. Only the Europeans, by dint of their advancements in sailing primarily, brought that ethnic cleansing mentality to every continent on the planet and dominated 80% of the world’s population.

    It’s not that the Europeans are inherently more dastardly or anything. It’s just that they went out and spread their violence before anyone. So when I criticize, for example, that the genocidal Europeans are the only ones with documented opinions on that Wikipedia page, that’s not to say they are inherently more violent than the Chinese, just historically more violent. It’s a problem of reality, not a problem of some mystical aspect of their being.








  • You’re so funny. You do realize that for 100 - 150 years after every Euro-liberal revolution the masses of people were destitute while the elite became insanely rich? You think the robber barons were an anomaly? Why do you think the labor movement happened? It wasn’t because people were well taken care of.

    Meanwhile in every communist revolution mass poverty alleviation was the primary driver of economic organization, ending centuries of famine cycles, lifting 100s of millions out of abject poverty, and it only took them between 10 and 30 years to establish the industrial and economic base to do it. In the USSR rent was less than 10% of person’s income. In China, a child laborerer on a rice farm in 1949 is today sitting in a car that park itself.

    Stalin came from poverty and ethnic minority, became the most powerful man in the USSR and died with almost nothing to his name except some clothes and few pieces of furniture.

    Would I prefer a system that governs for the benefit of the masses? Absolutely.

    What’s funny is that you are so adamant that having a vote in a liberal democracy matters so much that it’s evil to not have exactly the type of voting system from liberal democracy, and yet that self same voting system is exactly what allowed the oligarchs to maintain and grow their power for 250 years without anyone ever being able to stop them.

    Yes, I would gladly abandon this farce of a democracy for something that actually helped the masses instead of the system that protects the opulent minority from the will of the majority (to use the words of American founding father and 5th president James Madison).





  • only the definition that you prefer is valid. Not the actual meaning of the word

    So the meaning of a word is how it’s used. This case with Jefferies, the meaning of the word is “famous black man like Tupac”. That’s the meaning. We know this because the person assigning it to him is not speaking in Arabic, and not applying the same moniker to white people.

    So even in that basis alone, the moniker may as well be “AIPAC Blackman”. Because that’s literally the extent of thought being put into it.

    The problem is that Tupac’s name is not just some accident of history. It is a deliberate choice. Therefore it comes with meaning.

    Meaning is constructed. It’s not something found in a dictionary, it’s a participatory process.

    This is true for plenty of other names: Hitler, Trump, Gandhi, etc. Imagine calling JD Vance’s wife “A Hot Ma Gandhi”. Not only is it offensive simply by virtue of the dehumanization that comes from decontextualizing a name based on ethnicity or race and just applying a famous name of one member of that community to another (like calling all Chinese people Lee or Ching), but it’s ALSO applying a name with the baggage if honor to a person who doesn’t deserve that honor.

    I wouldn’t be offended on behalf of the Gandhi family. I would just find it offensive and ignorant.

    This is like that. I am not upset on behalf of the Shakur’s, I am upset as me, because it’s an ignorant and offensive name for all of these reasons. And you defending it is a lot like the good old boys saying “what are you some kind of Indian lover? If they don’t like it let them come tell me to my face that they don’t like it”. It’s not a good look


  • So you missed the entire history of the contemporary black American Shakur family, where the name was adopted by Black Panther James Coston as part of his conversion to Islam after Malcolm X’s assassination? Where that others in the Panthers choose to adopt that name for themselves as a sign of solidarity, respect, and commitment to black liberation? Where Tupac’s mother changed her name for this reason, and changed her son’s name as well.

    The only thing linking Jeffries’s moniker and the Shakur family name is that AIPAC and Tupac end in the same three letters. It both assigns a very specific radical revolutionary name to an opponent, which in and of itself is disrespectful to the name and the family, but then does so simply because Jeffries is black, because none of the white people in Congress that take money from AIPAC are called “AIPAC Shakur”.

    There’s really not a single legitimate reason to use the moniker, and there are at least 2 reasons not to.

    To be clear, Jeffries deserve an insult. Using Shakur as part of the insult is insulting to the Shakurs. Jeffries has not earned that name.