Or, they do super well by beating people up and taking their things? The person who happily takes from those weaker than them is often not terribly bothered by you giving them the cold shoulder. And they probably have their own coterie of hangers-on to provide them companionship. How do you handle such a person, since simple disfellowship is insufficient?
- 0 Posts
- 327 Comments
It’s worth noting that the Zapatistas aren’t an anarchist group and make no claim to being one. They do have a non-centralized leadership structure of elders who enforce a “restorative justice” system that forces people who perpetrate crimes to do community service. This does require a form of tribunal that local leaders manage.
But, to be clear, all this requires hierarchy, authority, and coercion in ways that most anarchists would reject. Which is the core of the issue.
You say “invent a scenario” as if people don’t use violence to get what they want all the time.
You can’t “move on without them” if they refuse to leave and continue recidivate. How do you deal with such a person in your ideal, anarchist society? It seems like your solution is to just pretend it wouldn’t be a problem, which is absurd on its face. You’re basically saying no one would decide to steal your food because everyone would just make their own instead. History shows that being incredibly unlikely.
How do you distinguish between tribal organization and anarchist society. Both are small communities that are “self governing.” What is the key difference in your mind?
And if they refuse to leave? If they simply take your things by violence? What then?
Historically, the answer is to have them lynched, which does solve the problem, but I think most reasonable people would agree that isn’t something we want to bring back.
And violence against innocents would be punished like in any society.
I think this is the part I get hung up on. The way this has historically been handled is lynchings. The town thinks you murdered those kids? They lynch you. The town drunk says he saw you doing devil worship? Lynched. You piss off someone with more social capital than you? Another lynching.
While I agree that this is self-ordering in some sense, I don’t find it to be morally acceptable. Justice requires systematics that anarchy simply can’t provide. And while no justice system is perfect, I think we can all agree that going back to lynchings is probably not the right direction.
I think that you’re not wrong, but the historical way that these societies have handled antisocial behavior is via lynchings. I don’t know that this model works if you don’t bring back lynchings, which I personally find unpalatable.
One could argue that most of the people who want to go all Mad Max do in fact break the law to do so, and are now in jail. Or do you think that disturbed people who want to do harm to the general populace don’t exist?
I think it’s a bit straw-man-y to say that people who argue that “without law there would be chaos” are saying they want chaos. In fact, it’s the opposite. There is clearly some minority slice of humanity that just wants to cause others harm, and we need some sort of structure/order to keep those people from causing harm. I find that most people advocating for anarchy don’t really have a good answer to how we handle antisocial behavior.
What happens when someone selfishly refuses to contribute to the common good? Or worse, actively attempts to disrupt it?
Ah, yes, I forgot. Those two famously still in power people… checks notes… Barak Obama and Joe Biden.
So, it depends on what you mean by “real.”
There was a bill that got integrated into the NDAA that allowed for increased technology sharing and network communication between the US and Israeli militaries.
While I agree it’s not good, I don’t know that it’s even close to the “full integration” that a lot of the media has catastrophicized it as.
Here’s the wiki article for it, if you want to actually see what it says: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States-Israel_FUTURES_Act
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
News@lemmy.world•Alabama voters put Pledge of Allegiance, school prayer in the state constitution
1·8 days agoI did in fact see it was a different person I was responding to. I tried to make my language target neutral. I settled on “rebuttal,” as it felt like it restarted the attribution to responding to my post, not your OP, though I suppose using “double down” probably did the opposite. Regardless, I did recognize it was a different person.
But let’s be clear. Bald faced prejudice is not rhetorical exaggeration. It’s not rhetorical exaggeration to say “black people are usually criminals.” Are some black people criminals? Sure. But to pretend that it is therefore somehow intrinsic to that community isn’t innocent point making. It’s racism.
And sure, that guy was joking. But let’s say someone says something racist, I call out the racism, and then someone makes a racist joke in response. I don’t think it’s “not understanding humor,” to call it out when I’ve already established the problem is the racism.
Prejudice and tribalism isn’t a good thing. Even when it’s against people you don’t like. Perhaps especially then.
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
News@lemmy.world•Alabama voters put Pledge of Allegiance, school prayer in the state constitution
73·9 days agoI don’t know that doubling down on your own ignorance and prejudices is exactly the snappy rebuttal you seem to think it is.
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
News@lemmy.world•Alabama voters put Pledge of Allegiance, school prayer in the state constitution
144·9 days agoThis stereotype is exactly as true as the idea that, in California, there are parents cutting penises off of their babies because they want to force them to be transgender. And it comes from the same place of tribalism and ignorance.
I’m not saying Alabama doesn’t have problems. Obviously it does. But this weird, “hurr-durr they marry their sisters,” thing is stupid and offensive.
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
News@lemmy.world•Young co-pilot, 20, named as one of nine victims of deadly Florida plane crash
17·13 days agoTrue and fair. But, on the flip side, I don’t remember the last time I saw a private jet plow through a crowd of protestors. So, like, there are trade-offs I guess.
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
News@lemmy.world•Young co-pilot, 20, named as one of nine victims of deadly Florida plane crash
252·13 days agoAs opposed to cars, which have famously few consequences when things go wrong.
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
Programmer Humor@programming.dev•Am I the only one bothered by this?
2·27 days agoOof, man. You alright?
Like, I don’t feel like I was being that condescending. Maybe a bit sarcastic at worst. Feels like you’re projecting some past stuff into this pretty hard.
Genuine beat, you’re worth something man. You have value and people care about you. I hope you’re having a good day.
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
Programmer Humor@programming.dev•Am I the only one bothered by this?
151·27 days agoThey did say generally. They also said “no matter how small their business is.”
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
Programmer Humor@programming.dev•Am I the only one bothered by this?
105·27 days agoOkay, so if they employ someone part time to help with the bookkeeping, then I’m supposed to hate them, but not before? Just trying to understand.
testfactor@lemmy.worldto
Programmer Humor@programming.dev•Am I the only one bothered by this?
2812·27 days agoSo running a craft studio and selling your art direct to people in your area makes you a class traitor now?
Man, I’m having trouble keeping up with who we’re supposed to hate guys.

I was thinking banditry and rape, but if you want to pretend that I hate the mentally ill so that you can ignore the issues raised, that’s your prerogative I guess.