

yet they still prolong civil wars for selfish gain
Would be interested in what specific conflicts you’re referring to. I am definitely critical of China for engaging in trade with essentially zero care for the conditions of the state they are trading with. Israel being the obvious criticism. Are those types of trade relations with countries what you’re referring to? I agree if that’s what you mean.
They still let their companies do whatever
This is in conflict to the normal complaints of China “disappearing” people. So, are you saying they don’t do that? Because the famous cases of this are from businessmen that start speaking against the party, or doing actual social crimes.
I have criticism of China’s free speech restrictions on individual citizens. But to say that China “let’s companies do whatever they want” is in complete contradiction to the countless “violations of freedom” that the Western media speaks about. Because those are entirely made up of the capitalist of China stepping out of line with the party; or engaging in social murder like crimes.
They aren’t better out of benevolence, but because they have a different imperial strategy.
I hear the language of the left here being used in a non material way. If you’re someone that has the word “imperial strategy” in your vocabulary it shocks me to hear someone describe a system based on idealism as the core. “The purpose of a system is what it does.” Its odd to conclude with a point of criticism that is rooted in idealism. It is rooted in the western idea that China is just “waiting for its moment of attack” with no material reason to conclude that.
If China wanted to start being aggressive and start it’s Imperialist expansion there was no better time than the Iran invasion. You think America was ready to defend Taiwan when it was taking interceptors out of Korea to send them to Israel? Yet China decided to “wait” and instead reduce its purchases of oil to assist it’s trade partners in East Asia.
At a certain point this “waiting for the right moment” Imperialist China narrative needs to die. They have proven their intentions are based entirely on offering a less parasitic form of trade than the US offers. One that is entirely without the use of military conflict.
I’m not sure how you can call that imperial strategy in a world where US Imperialism still exists. If the US was gone. Sure, it would be insane to engage in trade relations with states like Israel. But, you’re criticism is in a vacuum and not in the context of the cold war being waged against China by the west.


Opening with a straw man is not a good start. I never said that. I said that your position seemed to be void of understanding how a country acts within the context of global capitalism. It’s like being critical towards Cuba in a vacuum and not considering the trade embargo. Don’t put words in my mouth.
Starting with this bad faith interpretation is not at all “fascinating”. You’re just trying to jump to your conclusion instead of trying to respond to what I actually said. The rest of that first paragraph isn’t worth responding to because it’s around a straw man you built. It’s obvious when you’re trying to make my perspective “too absurd to argue with”. It’s because you’re not arguing with it.
Your second paragraph says everything. You’re admitting to the fact that China is far far better as a world power than the West. I have similar criticisms of China. But China has time and time again adjusted it’s policy to fix those criticisms from its people and the world. It’s just silly to group them into “empire” in anyway similar to how that word has historically been used to define expansion through military force or war like economic policies. There is no material basis to call them by that word. I don’t get how you can write your second paragraph and then conclude with “empire”. I understand the idea of soft power. But soft power is something that enables the maintenance of something that was taken through hard power. You seem to be confusing the tactics of China with the maintenance of empire the West uses.
And I’m getting interrupted. So that where my response ends unfortunately.